top of page
Search

TUSD's Educational Performance Problem: Are Students Receiving the Education They Deserve?

6 hours ago
12 min read

A review of student achievement, chronic absenteeism, academic recovery, operational effectiveness, and accountability at Tucson Unified School District


John C. Blackshire, Jr. The Accountware Group | November 20, 2026


The Fundamental Purpose of a School District Is Student Achievement

Tucson Unified School District (TUSD) exists to educate children.


Its primary responsibility is not to maintain buildings, administer budgets, employ personnel, or operate a large bureaucracy. Those activities are necessary only because they support the district's central mission: providing students with the knowledge, skills, and educational opportunities they need to succeed.


The ultimate measure of an educational institution is whether its students are learning.


For TUSD, the evidence raises substantial questions about how effectively the district is accomplishing that mission.


During the past three years, state education records, national academic research, internal audits, and newspaper investigations have documented troubling conditions involving student attendance, reading achievement, academic recovery, and educational accountability.


At the same time, the district faces declining enrollment and substantial financial pressure.

The question taxpayers, parents, and the Governing Board should be asking is straightforward:


Is TUSD organizing its resources, operations, and management systems around measurable improvements in student achievement—or is the organization becoming increasingly focused on maintaining itself?


1. Chronic Absenteeism: An Educational System Cannot Succeed When Students Are Not in Class

Perhaps the most disturbing educational performance indicator at TUSD is chronic absenteeism.


Arizona considers a student chronically absent when the student misses at least 10% of the school year, generally 18 days in a 180-day calendar.


According to Arizona Department of Education data reported by the Arizona Daily Star and other sources, TUSD's chronic absenteeism rates were:

School year

Chronically absent students

2021–2022

50.6%

2022–2023

34.6%

2023–2024

33.8%

2024–2025

43.6%

These results tell a troubling story.


TUSD made meaningful progress following the pandemic, reducing chronic absenteeism from approximately 51% to 34%.


But during the 2024–2025 school year, the rate increased nearly 10 percentage points.


That reversed much of the earlier improvement.


The 2024–2025 rate was approximately 19.8 percentage points above Arizona's statewide rate of 23.8%.


In July 2026, the Arizona Daily Star reported that TUSD had the highest chronic absenteeism rate among Pima County school districts.


When approximately 44% of students are chronically absent, attendance is no longer an isolated student discipline issue. It is a districtwide educational performance problem.


Students who are not regularly present cannot consistently benefit from classroom instruction, academic interventions, tutoring, or other educational services.


The district cannot reasonably expect sustained improvements in reading and mathematics without addressing the instructional time lost through absenteeism.


The problem is especially severe among vulnerable students

The 2024–2025 data showed particularly high absenteeism rates for several student populations:

  • Economically disadvantaged students: 48.0%.

  • Hispanic students: 47.6%.

  • Students experiencing homelessness: 58.1%.


These disparities require targeted interventions rather than a uniform disciplinary response.


Economic hardship, transportation difficulties, housing instability, illness, and family responsibilities can contribute to absenteeism.


The district cannot control every underlying cause. But management is responsible for establishing an effective system to identify students at risk, coordinate available support, and measure whether interventions improve attendance.


The central accountability question is whether TUSD can demonstrate that its attendance interventions produce sustained results.


Sources: Arizona Department of Education data reported by the Arizona Daily Star, July 18, 2026; EdTribune, April 16, 2026.


2. Attendance Control Failures Were Identified Years Before the 2025 Attendance Crisis

The attendance problem is particularly concerning because TUSD had already been warned about weaknesses in its attendance reporting and monitoring processes.


An August 2024 investigation by KOLD News 13 examined an Arizona Department of Education audit from 2021 and a subsequent TUSD internal audit from April 2024.


The reporting described deficiencies in student attendance documentation, reporting accuracy, and intervention procedures.


The internal audit reviewed a sample of 420 student records and identified discrepancies between reported attendance information and supporting documentation.


The audit also identified concerns involving chronic tardiness, excessive absences, and insufficient documentation of administrative or student-support interventions.


The earlier state audit resulted in a financial settlement reportedly totaling $230,000.

These findings raise two distinct concerns.


First, inaccurate attendance reporting creates compliance and funding risks.


Second, unreliable attendance information can impair the district's ability to identify students requiring intervention.


A school district needs accurate, timely attendance information to determine which students are missing instruction and whether its intervention programs are effective.


If TUSD Management cannot consistently produce reliable attendance records, how can it demonstrate that its attendance improvement programs are working?


The documented deficiencies warrant an examination of the corrective actions implemented after the 2021 and 2024 audits.


The district should be able to demonstrate when each deficiency was corrected, who was accountable, and whether subsequent testing confirmed sustained compliance.


Source: KOLD News 13, Valerie Cavazos, August 26, 2024.


3. Reading Achievement: Students Are Not Recovering Lost Ground Fast Enough

Reading proficiency is foundational to nearly every other educational outcome.

Students who struggle with reading may also experience difficulties in mathematics, science, social studies, and career preparation.


The national Education Recovery Scorecard, developed through research involving Harvard and Stanford, provides an important independent assessment of TUSD's academic performance.


Its February 2025 district report compared academic achievement before the pandemic with results through 2024.


The findings for grades three through eight were concerning.


Reading achievement

The report measured performance in grade-level equivalents relative to the 2019 national average.

Year

TUSD reading performance

2019

-0.27

2022

-0.32

2024

-0.84

Between 2022 and 2024, TUSD's average reading performance declined by approximately 0.53 grade-level equivalents.


Relative to 2019, the decline was approximately 0.58 grade-level equivalents.


These are standardized comparative measures, not a statement that every student was individually six months behind.


Nevertheless, the direction of the trend is important.


Rather than recovering lost reading achievement between 2022 and 2024, TUSD's measured reading performance deteriorated further.


This should have triggered a rigorous evaluation of the district's literacy curriculum, instructional practices, intervention programs, and academic monitoring systems.


Management should be able to explain which literacy interventions were implemented, how much they cost, which students received services, and what measurable improvements resulted.


Source: Education Recovery Scorecard, Tucson Unified District (4403), Arizona, February 2025.


4. Mathematics Achievement: Progress Exists, but the Longer-Term Problem Remains

TUSD's mathematics performance presents a more complicated picture.


The 2025 Education Recovery Scorecard reported the following mathematics results for grades three through eight:

Year

TUSD mathematics performance

2019

-0.15

2022

-0.81

2024

-0.81

Mathematics performance declined substantially between 2019 and 2022 and showed essentially no recovery through 2024.


However, the updated 2026 Education Scorecard identified TUSD as one of several Arizona districts demonstrating notable mathematics recovery relative to comparable districts.


That improvement deserves recognition.


It also illustrates why school district performance should be evaluated using multiple measures over time.


Improvement relative to comparable districts does not necessarily mean that students have fully recovered to pre-pandemic achievement levels or reached grade-level proficiency.


The Governing Board should examine both absolute achievement and academic growth.


The relevant questions include whether students are meeting grade-level standards, whether those below proficiency are catching up, and whether gains are sustained across successive school years.


Sources: Education Recovery Scorecard, February 2025; Education Scorecard, Arizona 2025 Results, May 13, 2026.


5. Achievement Gaps: Educational Services Are Not Producing Equal Outcomes

A March 2025 Arizona Daily Star investigation examined TUSD's academic recovery efforts and reported continuing achievement gaps affecting economically disadvantaged students and several racial and ethnic student populations.


The investigation found that improvements were uneven and that some student groups continued to experience academic setbacks.


TUSD officials described targeted interventions, including instructional framework improvements, teacher training, and programs intended to support students performing below proficiency standards.


These efforts may provide benefits.


However, the existence of an intervention program is not evidence of its effectiveness.


An organization must distinguish between activities performed and results achieved.


For example, management may report that teachers completed professional development, tutoring services expanded, or additional instructional specialists were hired.


Those are measures of activity.


The more important measures are whether participating students improved their reading and mathematics skills, whether proficiency gaps narrowed, and whether the improvements continued after the intervention ended.


Achievement gaps are influenced by factors beyond a school district's direct control, including poverty, housing instability, language barriers, and access to educational resources.


Nevertheless, TUSD should be able to demonstrate how its instructional programs address these conditions and what outcomes they produce.


The proper management objective is not simply to provide more educational services. It is to demonstrate that those services improve student learning.


Source: Arizona Daily Star, Jessica Votipka, March 9, 2025.


6. Federal Pandemic Funding: What Educational Results Were Achieved?

TUSD received substantial federal pandemic relief funding intended to address educational disruption and support student recovery.


The Arizona Daily Star reported that TUSD received approximately $172.9 million through ESSER III funding.


The district used portions of its pandemic funding for learning recovery specialists, counselors, social workers, tutors, and summer educational programs.


Approximately $3.6 million was reportedly allocated to learning recovery specialists.


These expenditures may have addressed important student needs.


But from an accountability perspective, spending money is not the same as achieving results.


The critical questions are:

  • What measurable academic outcomes were established before the funds were spent?

  • How many students received services?

  • What improvements occurred among participating students?

  • Were the results compared with appropriate benchmarks?

  • Which programs were continued after federal funding expired?

  • Did the district independently evaluate the effectiveness of its recovery expenditures?


The Education Recovery Scorecard's reading results through 2024 raise questions about the effectiveness of the district's overall literacy recovery strategy.


They do not, by themselves, establish that specific federally funded programs failed. A credible program evaluation must account for student characteristics, participation, implementation quality, and other factors affecting outcomes.


Nevertheless, the district should be able to provide taxpayers with a clear accounting of the educational results associated with its recovery expenditures.


A public school district should measure the return on educational investments primarily through improvements in student outcomes, not merely through the amount of money spent.


7. Declining Enrollment: A Warning About Educational and Financial Sustainability

TUSD continues to lose students.


The Arizona Auditor General's January 2026 financial risk analysis reported that the district's weighted student count had declined approximately 8.99% since fiscal year 2022.


In September 2026, Arizona Public Media reported that TUSD was anticipating another enrollment decline, including a particularly substantial reduction in kindergarten enrollment.


Declining enrollment has several possible causes.


These include changing birth rates, population movements, housing patterns, charter school competition, private education alternatives, and family preferences.


It would be inappropriate to attribute the entire decline to dissatisfaction with TUSD's educational quality.


However, educational performance is one factor that families may consider when choosing schools.


The district should evaluate whether enrollment losses are associated with particular schools, grade levels, neighborhoods, academic outcomes, or student experiences.


This analysis should distinguish demographic changes from student transfers to other educational providers.


The financial consequences are substantial.


As enrollment declines, the district receives less enrollment-based funding while continuing to operate facilities and programs that may have been designed for a larger student population.


The Auditor General identified TUSD as one of Arizona's highest-financial-risk school districts in January 2026.


The district's financial position therefore creates another important question:


Can TUSD maintain and improve educational quality while restructuring an operating model that is becoming increasingly difficult to finance?


Financial restructuring and educational improvement must be managed together.


8. School Attendance Is Also a Student Support and Engagement Problem

In September 2026, Arizona Public Media reported that more than 5,800 TUSD students had attendance rates below 80% at the end of the preceding school year.


These students were missing at least one out of every five school days.


The same reporting described discussions about revising attendance policies and expanding family outreach.


TUSD has pursued initiatives involving community liaisons, family resource centers, attendance awareness campaigns, and student support services.


Those initiatives are relevant responses to a difficult problem.


However, management should establish measurable objectives for each initiative.


For example, the district should track how quickly students are identified after repeated absences, how often families are contacted, what barriers are identified, which interventions are provided, and whether attendance improves.


The effectiveness of a program should be evaluated by its outcomes, not by the number of meetings held or personnel assigned.


A districtwide attendance management system should also distinguish students experiencing illness, housing instability, transportation difficulties, disengagement, and other circumstances.


Different causes require different interventions.


A successful attendance program is not simply one that records absences accurately. It is one that helps students return to regular participation in learning.


9. The Governing Board Needs an Educational Performance Dashboard

A school district with approximately 37,000 students cannot be managed effectively through isolated presentations, anecdotal success stories, and periodic reports.


The Governing Board should receive a consistent educational performance dashboard that allows members to evaluate whether student outcomes are improving.


At a minimum, that dashboard should include:

  1. Third-grade reading proficiency, including year-over-year improvement.

  2. Mathematics proficiency and academic growth by grade level.

  3. Chronic absenteeism and average daily attendance.

  4. Four-year and five-year high school graduation rates.

  5. Student dropout and credit-recovery rates.

  6. Achievement gaps for economically disadvantaged students, English learners, students with disabilities, and other reported groups.

  7. Student enrollment, retention, and transfers.

  8. Teacher vacancies, turnover, and instructional continuity.

  9. Academic intervention effectiveness, including student progress and program costs.


These indicators should be reported by school and, where appropriate, student subgroup.


Results should be compared with prior years, district targets, Arizona averages, and suitably comparable districts.


The dashboard should distinguish measures of educational activity from measures of educational achievement.


TUSD Management should also identify the executive responsible for each performance objective and explain significant variances.


A dashboard without accountability is merely another report.


10. Internal Audit Should Examine Educational Operating Effectiveness

Internal Audit has an important role in evaluating the processes that support educational achievement.


That does not mean Internal Audit should determine curriculum or substitute its judgment for qualified educational professionals.


It means Internal Audit can independently assess whether management has designed and implemented effective systems for achieving established educational objectives.


Potential audit subjects include attendance monitoring, student intervention tracking, academic performance data integrity, enrollment forecasting, educational program expenditures, and management's monitoring of corrective actions.


For example, an audit of chronic absenteeism could evaluate whether student records are accurate, intervention criteria are consistently applied, case management activities are documented, and management receives reliable information about program outcomes.


An audit of academic recovery programs could examine whether objectives were established, resources were used as authorized, performance measures were reliable, and management evaluated program effectiveness.


These are legitimate operational audit subjects.


The purpose of Internal Audit is not to determine whether management is busy. It is to provide assurance about whether governance, risk management, and control processes support the organization's objectives.


For a school district, those objectives must ultimately include student achievement.


11. TUSD's Educational Challenges Require More Than Another Strategic Plan

TUSD's academic and operational problems cannot be resolved merely by adopting additional policies or announcing new initiatives.


The district needs a management process that connects educational objectives, resources, responsibilities, performance measures, and corrective actions.


That process should begin with clearly defined student achievement targets.


Management should then determine which instructional and student-support activities are most likely to achieve those targets, allocate resources accordingly, and monitor results.


When results fall short, management should identify the causes and adjust its approach.


This is the basic management cycle of planning, execution, measurement, evaluation, and corrective action.


It is also consistent with the principles of effective internal control and enterprise risk management.


A mature educational management system should make it possible for the Governing Board to answer four questions:


What student outcomes are we trying to achieve? What are we doing to achieve them? Are the actions working? What changes are being made when they are not?


Without reliable answers, the Board cannot adequately evaluate management's effectiveness.


12. Who Is Accountable for Student Achievement?

Teachers are responsible for delivering instruction and supporting students.


Principals are responsible for leading their schools.


District administrators are responsible for designing and managing educational programs and supporting operations.


The Superintendent is responsible for administering the district and implementing Board policy.


The Governing Board is responsible for establishing policy, overseeing district performance, and holding the Superintendent accountable for results.


Parents, students, and community organizations also play essential roles.


Accountability must therefore be appropriately distributed.


But it cannot be avoided.


When chronic absenteeism approaches 44%, reading performance deteriorates over multiple years, and achievement gaps persist, district leadership should be expected to explain the causes, the corrective actions being implemented, and the evidence that those actions are working.


The Governing Board should not accept program descriptions as substitutes for measurable outcomes.


Nor should it assume that increasing expenditures will automatically improve educational achievement.


Educational accountability requires demonstrating that public resources are being converted into meaningful learning opportunities and measurable student progress.


Conclusion: The Students Must Come First

TUSD faces serious financial challenges.


But its most important challenge is educational.


The district's chronic absenteeism rate, persistent reading difficulties, uneven academic recovery, and historical attendance control deficiencies raise substantial concerns about the effectiveness of its educational operating systems.


The evidence also shows that improvement is possible.


TUSD previously achieved a substantial reduction in chronic absenteeism, and more recent national research identified encouraging mathematics recovery relative to comparable districts.


Those results demonstrate why performance must be evaluated carefully and continuously rather than through isolated statistics.


Nevertheless, the district's educational outcomes require sustained attention.


The Governing Board should demand clear academic objectives, reliable performance information, independent evaluations of significant programs, and documented corrective actions when results fall short.


The district must also ensure that financial restructuring does not undermine essential instructional services.


TUSD's buildings, administrative structure, budgets, policies, and programs exist to support the education of children.


They are not ends in themselves.


The ultimate question is not how much money TUSD spends on education. It is whether students are acquiring the knowledge and skills that public education is supposed to provide.


That is the measure by which the district's educational performance should be judged.


Sources and References

  1. Arizona Department of Education, Arizona School Report Cards: https://azreportcards.azed.gov/

  2. Education Recovery Scorecard, Tucson Unified District (4403), Arizona, February 2025: https://educationrecoveryscorecard.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/report_AZ_0408800_tucson-unified-district-4403.pdf

  3. Education Scorecard, Arizona 2025 Results, May 13, 2026: https://educationscorecard.org/states/arizona/

  4. Arizona Daily Star, Academic Recovery Efforts in TUSD Show Mixed Results, March 9, 2025: https://tucson.com/news/local/education/precollegiate/article_d41f3ee2-eefb-11ef-b250-7f31ef9a0e52.html

  5. Arizona Daily Star, Tucson Unified's Chronic Absenteeism Rate Spikes to 44%, July 18, 2026: https://tucson.com/news/local/education/precollegiate/article_e60a2fd4-d86f-41c1-b193-a525a2b96296.html

  6. KOLD News 13, Audits Reveal Tucson USD Told to Repay State Funds, August 26, 2024: https://www.kold.com/2024/08/27/audits-reveal-tucson-usd-told-repay-state-funds-could-risk-losing-more-over-student-attendance-reporting/

  7. Arizona Public Media, TUSD Reviews Attendance Policy as Enrollment Steadily Declines, September 11, 2026: https://www.azpm.org/news/2026-09-11/231169-tusd-reviews-attendance-policy-as-enrollment-steadily-declines

  8. Arizona Auditor General, Tucson Unified School District Financial Risk Analysis, January 2026: https://frisk.azauditor.gov/District/Tucson_Unified_School_District

  9. EdTribune, Tucson Unified's Chronic Absenteeism Spiked Nearly 10 Points in One Year, April 16, 2026: https://az.edtribune.com/az/2026-04-16-az-tucson-reversal/


Editorial note: This article evaluates documented educational outcomes and management processes. It does not establish that every unfavorable result was caused by district management. School-level proficiency, graduation, staffing, and program effectiveness data require additional detailed examination before definitive conclusions can be reached about individual schools or programs.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

479-200-4373

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook

©2026 by The Accountware Group. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page