TUSD's $16.1 Million Accounting Error: Did the District's Own Budgets Reveal the Problem?
John C. Blackshire, Jr. The Accountware Group | November 2026
An examination of TUSD's FY2024–FY2026 budgets and Annual Financial Reports provides evidence supporting the CFO's explanation of a major revenue allocation error. But important questions remain about why the error occurred, how it was calculated, and why internal controls failed to detect it.
The $16.1 Million Question
On October 22, 2026, Tucson Unified School District Chief Financial Officer Ricky Hernández informed the District's Audit Committee that a revenue apportionment error had resulted in $16,148,172 being incorrectly allocated between the Maintenance & Operation (M&O) Fund and Unrestricted Capital Outlay (UCO) Fund.
According to the CFO, the correction required reallocating that amount from UCO to M&O.
The CFO explained that the error affected FY2025 ending fund balances and, consequently, FY2026 beginning fund balances. He further stated that the correction did not create additional District revenue or change the combined fund balance.
That explanation raises an important question:
Do TUSD's own financial records support the existence of an allocation error?
An examination of the District's adopted budgets and Annual Financial Reports provides evidence that they do.
However, understanding that evidence requires distinguishing between two different financial measurements: budget capacity and actual revenue apportionment.
1. What TUSD Budgeted for M&O and UCO
Arizona school districts maintain separate funds for maintenance and operations and unrestricted capital expenditures.
The District's adopted expenditure budgets establish the budget limits applicable to those funds.
Using the budget limits in TUSD's adopted expenditure budget documents, the following allocations can be calculated.
Fiscal year | M&O budget limit | UCO budget limit | M&O share | UCO share |
FY2024 | $394,923,920 | $37,812,666 | 91.26% | 8.74% |
FY2025 | $387,951,376 | $19,536,541 | 95.21% | 4.79% |
FY2026 | $380,788,858 | $17,321,906 | 95.65% | 4.35% |
So the FY2025 Budget shows how the CFO reduced the UCO share of these funds from 8.74 percent to 4.79 percent.
Sources: TUSD FY2024, FY2025, and FY2026 adopted Arizona School District Annual Expenditure Budgets, page 1.
These percentages represent each fund's share of the combined budget limits. They are not necessarily the legally required revenue apportionment percentages.
Nevertheless, the changes are significant.
Between FY2024 and FY2025:
M&O's budget limit decreased approximately $7.0 million.
UCO's budget limit decreased approximately $18.3 million.
UCO's share of combined budget limits declined from 8.74% to 4.79%.
In other words, the relative budget capacity of the UCO fund declined substantially.
If the revenue apportionment process failed to reflect applicable changes in budget capacity, revenues could have continued to flow into UCO in amounts inconsistent with the revised budget structure.
That is consistent with the type of error described by the CFO.
2. What the Annual Financial Reports Show
The next step is to examine how property tax and State aid revenues were actually reported between the two funds.
For consistency, this analysis defines State aid as State Equalization Assistance (revenue code 3110) plus Additional State Aid (revenue code 3120). Property taxes are revenue code 1110.
FY2024 Actual Revenue Allocation
Revenue source | M&O | UCO | UCO percentage |
Property taxes | $158,215,687 | $19,721,875 | 11.08% |
State aid | $186,285,076 | $13,791,155 | 6.89% |
Combined | $344,500,763 | $33,513,030 | 8.87% |
The FY2024 AFR shows that 8.87% of the combined property tax and specified State aid revenues were reported in UCO.
That percentage was relatively close to the 8.74% UCO share of combined adopted budget limits.
This similarity does not establish that the apportionment was correct. Property tax and State aid allocations are subject to their own legal and accounting requirements.
FY2025 Actual Revenue Allocation
Revenue source | M&O | UCO | UCO percentage |
Property taxes | $160,148,129 | $16,551,256 | 9.37% |
State aid | $186,327,269 | $13,787,937 | 6.89% |
Combined | $346,475,398 | $30,339,193 | 8.05% |
Source: TUSD FY2025 Annual Financial Report, page 1.
The FY2025 AFR shows that UCO continued to receive 8.05% of combined property tax and specified State aid revenues.
But its share of combined adopted budget limits had declined to 4.79%.
That difference deserves examination.
FY2026 Actual Revenue Allocation
TUSD's FY2026 adopted budget establishes a UCO share of combined budget limits of approximately 4.35%.
However, the FY2026 AFR property tax and State aid amounts were not established from the documents available for this review.
Therefore, a verified FY2026 actual revenue apportionment percentage cannot yet be reported.
The FY2026 AFR is particularly important because it should be examined alongside the $16.1 million correction recorded during that fiscal year.
The auditor must distinguish the original revenue allocations from the beginning fund balance and cash adjustments used to correct the prior-year error.
3. The Three-Year Comparison
The following table summarizes what can presently be established.
Fiscal year | UCO share of adopted budget limits | UCO share of actual property tax and State aid revenue |
FY2024 | 8.74% | 8.87% |
FY2025 | 4.79% | 8.05% |
FY2026 | 4.35% | 5.51% |
The most important observation is the change between FY2024 and FY2025.
UCO's share of combined budget limits fell by approximately 3.95 percentage points.
But UCO's share of the specified actual revenues fell by only approximately 0.82 percentage points.
The budget allocation changed much more sharply than the reported revenue allocation.
That difference is consistent with the CFO's explanation that the revenue allocation process did not properly reflect changes in budget capacity.
However, the percentages cannot be compared as though they were calculated using the same statutory formula.
The adopted expenditure budget ratio is an analytical indicator. It is not a substitute for the official apportionment calculation.
4. Does This Support the CFO's $16.1 Million Error Statement?
The budget and AFR evidence supports three important observations.
First, TUSD materially reduced UCO budget capacity.
The adopted budget documents establish that UCO's budget limit declined from approximately $37.8 million in FY2024 to $19.5 million in FY2025.
This is not an assumption. It is documented in the District's adopted budget forms.
Second, the revenue allocation did not decline proportionately.
Despite the substantial reduction in UCO budget capacity, the FY2025 AFR continued to report more than $30.3 million in combined property tax and specified State aid revenue in UCO.
The difference between the movement in budget capacity and the movement in revenue allocation is a legitimate audit indicator.
Third, the CFO's explanation is consistent with the direction of the difference.
If revenues were incorrectly apportioned to UCO instead of M&O, correcting the error would increase M&O's fund balance and reduce UCO's fund balance.
That is precisely the direction of the correction described in the October 22 email.
These facts make the CFO's explanation plausible and provide corroborating circumstances.
They do not independently establish that the correct adjustment was $16,148,172.
5. Why the $16.1 Million Amount Still Requires Verification
The auditor cannot simply multiply FY2025 revenues by the difference between the budget-capacity percentages and reported revenue percentages.
Arizona's property tax and State aid apportionment requirements do not necessarily use one common percentage based on the combined expenditure budget limits.
Different revenue sources may require different calculations.
The proper audit procedure is to reconstruct the authorized FY2025 apportionment using the applicable adopted and revised budgets, budget capacity calculations, statutory requirements, and county distribution records.
The auditor should then compare the independently calculated amounts with the original revenue allocations.
Only that reconciliation can establish whether the correction should have been $16,148,172.
6. Why Did TUSD's Internal Controls Fail?
Even if the CFO's correction is entirely accurate, the underlying control failure remains significant.
The budget documents demonstrate that the relative capacity of the two funds changed substantially.
That should have prompted management to determine whether the revenue allocation instructions also required adjustment.
An effective internal control system should address several critical questions:
Who calculates the revenue allocation percentages when the annual budget is adopted or revised?
Who independently reviews the calculation?
Who communicates authorized changes to the Pima County School Superintendent?
Who reconciles actual revenue distributions against authorized allocations?
Why did the financial closing process fail to identify the apparent inconsistency before FY2025 was closed?
The CFO's email indicates that Financial Services intends to strengthen periodic reconciliations.
That is an appropriate area for corrective action, but it does not replace a documented root-cause analysis.
Management should establish whether the problem involved an incorrect calculation, a failure to communicate an approved change, an accounting system configuration problem, or ineffective review controls.
Each potential cause requires a different corrective response.
7. The Financial Reporting Consequences
The CFO stated that the correction did not change TUSD's combined fund balance.
That statement is mathematically consistent with an equal and opposite adjustment between two funds.
But it does not mean the error was inconsequential.
Governmental fund financial statements present individual fund balances because those balances communicate important information about the resources attributable to specific governmental purposes.
A $16.1 million misallocation could materially affect how readers interpret the financial condition of M&O and UCO, even when the District's combined balance remains unchanged.
The external auditor should determine whether the FY2025 financial statements were materially misstated, whether prior-period correction or disclosure requirements apply, and whether the error indicates a significant deficiency or material weakness in internal control.
The size of the adjustment alone does not automatically establish a material weakness.
8. What the Audit Committee Should Demand
The Audit Committee should request a complete reconciliation connecting the approved budget, authorized apportionment calculation, actual revenue distributions, and correcting journal entries.
At a minimum, that reconciliation should show:
The original FY2025 budget allocation inputs and resulting authorized apportionment percentages.
All FY2025 budget revisions affecting M&O and UCO.
The percentages originally communicated to Pima County.
The correct percentages independently calculated under applicable requirements.
Actual property tax and State aid revenues credited to each fund.
The exact calculation supporting the $16,148,172 correction.
The dates, approvals, and account numbers of the correcting entries.
Management's root-cause analysis and corrective action plan.
Internal Audit should independently test the reconciliation and the revised controls. The external auditor should address the financial statement implications.
Conclusion: The Numbers Support Investigating an Error, Not Closing the Investigation
TUSD's adopted budgets and AFRs provide meaningful evidence supporting the CFO's explanation.
The District substantially reduced UCO budget capacity for FY2025, while the percentage of property tax and State aid revenue reported in UCO declined much less.
That is consistent with a failure to update the apportionment calculation following changes in the District's budget structure.
The financial records therefore support the plausibility of the CFO's explanation. They do not yet prove the accuracy of the $16,148,172 correction.
The distinction matters.
The issue is no longer simply whether the CFO can offer a reasonable explanation. The District's own records provide a factual basis for examining that explanation.
Now the Audit Committee should require the calculation that connects those records to the correction.
If that calculation is independently verified, the focus should shift to why management's internal controls failed to prevent or detect such a substantial error.
If the calculation cannot be verified, the accounting correction itself remains unresolved.
Either way, the Audit Committee has a responsibility to obtain sufficient evidence before accepting management's conclusion.
Source documents
TUSD FY2024 Adopted School District Annual Expenditure Budget, July 11, 2023.
TUSD FY2025 Adopted School District Annual Expenditure Budget, July 15, 2024.
TUSD FY2026 Adopted School District Annual Expenditure Budget, July 15, 2025.
TUSD FY2024 and FY2025 Annual Financial Reports.
CFO Ricky Hernández, October 22, 2026, correspondence to the TUSD Audit Committee.
Arizona Auditor General, School District Frequently Asked Questions, Miscellaneous Question 8.
The percentages presented are calculated from published budget and AFR figures. Budget-capacity ratios should not be interpreted as legally prescribed revenue apportionment percentages. This article does not constitute an independent financial statement audit or a determination of wrongdoing.

Comments